Jonesborough, TN – December 17, 2024 – In a thought-provoking blog post titled The Importance of Evaluating Student Performance, a former college president with 13 years of experience at two institutions challenges the traditional methods of assessment in higher education. The post, published on the freethinking blog At a Slight Angle, advocates for a shift in focus from student evaluations of faculty to a more comprehensive evaluation of students’ performance beyond academic grades.
The post highlights the limitations of conventional grading systems, which primarily measure content proficiency, and calls for the inclusion of performance-based skills that are critical for success in the modern workforce. These skills include punctuality, teamwork, communication, problem-solving, and adaptability—qualities that employers consistently rank as essential for professional success.
“Higher education institutions have a responsibility to prepare students not just academically, but also professionally,” the author asserts. “Traditional grades fail to capture the soft skills that employers value most. It’s time for colleges and universities to adopt a more holistic approach to student evaluation.”
The post outlines key performance-based skills that should be integrated into student assessments, supported by research and examples from leading institutions such as the University of Southern California, Duke University, and the University of Michigan. These universities have implemented innovative programs that evaluate students on their ability to collaborate, communicate effectively, and adapt to real-world challenges.
Key Highlights from the Post:
- Punctuality and Attendance: Research shows that punctuality correlates with reliability and discipline, traits highly sought after by employers.
- Timeliness in Completing Work: Meeting deadlines reflects time management and prioritization skills, critical in any professional setting.
- Teamwork and Collaboration: Effective teamwork is among the top competencies employers seek, requiring clear communication and conflict resolution.
- Communication Skills: Strong verbal and written communication skills significantly enhance employability.
- Problem-Solving and Critical Thinking: These skills are crucial for navigating complex workplace challenges.
- Adaptability and Resilience: The ability to adapt to change and recover from setbacks is increasingly important in today’s fast-paced world.
The post also showcases examples of institutions that have successfully integrated performance-based assessments into their curricula. For instance, the University of Michigan’s Ross School of Business employs action-based learning projects where students are evaluated on teamwork, leadership, and communication. Similarly, Duke University emphasizes experiential learning through real-world projects that foster collaboration and problem-solving.
The post concludes with a call to action for higher education institutions to adopt comprehensive evaluation systems that align with employer expectations and prepare students for the demands of today’s job market. By doing so, colleges and universities can foster a more skilled, adaptable, and professional workforce.
To read the full blog post and join the conversation, visit robincapehart.substack.com. Readers are encouraged to subscribe to the blog to support this important dialogue on the future of higher education.
—
About At a Slight Angle
At a Slight Angle is a reader-supported blog dedicated to exploring critical issues in higher education. Written by a former college president, the blog offers insights and thought leadership on how institutions can better serve students and society.
Contact: Robin Capehart
Email: [email protected]
Phone: 615.335.0832